DoorDash Bought Instacart | CPG Acquisition | Left Hand Agency CPG High Five
DoorDash is buying Instacart for about $17 billion. If you use both apps like I do, the first thing you'll notice is the bill. The companies say DashPass and Instacart+ members will pay one membership fee instead of two. They haven't said what that fee will be, so hold your applause.
If you buy ads, the bigger news is that this puts two retail media businesses, each doing more than $1 billion a year in ad revenue, under one roof. Advertising is now about 30 percent of Instacart's revenue. DoorDash is buying an ad business along with the delivery one.
Before anyone rewrites a media plan, the deal isn't expected to close until the end of 2027 or the first half of 2028. It still needs regulators and shareholders to sign off, and we all remember how Kroger and Albertsons went. Until then, the two run as separate companies. There's also a wildcard nobody has answered: Instacart delivers for Walmart, and DoorDash stopped delivering for Walmart in 2022.
I'll say up front that when two ad tech companies combine, it usually isn't great for competition. Fewer places to buy means less leverage for the people buying. Still, there's real upside here for brands. Here's what I'm watching.
1. Dinner and groceries in one place

This is the part I'm most excited about. DoorDash knows what you order for dinner. Instacart knows what's going in your pantry. Put them together, and you can see buying occasions most platforms never connect.
Say a big chunk of shoppers order Chinese takeout every week. That's an audience I'd want to test for an Asian quick-prep meal brand. DoorDash's Brand Center already mixes purchase data with shelf-scan data in one targeting tool, so the plumbing is there.
The catch is that all of this is a "could." Nobody has said how or when the two ad businesses will combine. Merging restaurant and grocery data is also exactly the kind of thing regulators and privacy rules like to poke at. Worth watching, worth testing, not worth betting the plan on yet.
2. The grocer networks you buy may change owners
This is the one most people will miss. Instacart powers more than 310 grocery websites behind the scenes, the white-label side that lets grocers run their own online shops and retail media networks. Some of the regional grocer networks on your media plan today run on Instacart tech. After the deal, that tech belongs to DoorDash.
So take a look at who's actually behind the networks you buy. The one you think of as independent may share a parent with the one sitting next to it in your plan.
There's a silver lining for teams juggling a dozen platforms. Over time, consolidation could mean fewer logins, fewer reports and less time spent managing it all.
3. The shelf nobody sees

When your item is out of stock, somebody else picks the replacement. On Instacart, the default is "best match," which means the shopper's judgment call. Turning that off means clicking through settings item by item. Some shoppers have also said a refund can shrink their tip, so they'd rather swap than skip.
I've gotten subs so bad that I now go through my cart and pick approved replacements by hand. My ultimate test of loyalty is the brands I won't accept a sub for at all. Good Culture cottage cheese is on that list. Nothing else will do.
Most shoppers aren't that loyal, though. Ehrenberg-Bass research shows most people buy from a handful of brands in a category, so for most brands the sub moment is up for grabs. I haven't seen any public data on how those picks get made, and that's what makes me curious. If that moment ever becomes something brands can pay for, it could be the most valuable shelf in grocery. Until then, the job is the same as always: be the brand that comes to mind first, whether the one choosing is the shopper or an algorithm.
4. The real unlock is retail innovation in CPG
The week before this deal, Instacart pulled the plug on its smart carts. That's five years after paying $350 million for the company that made them, because retailers didn't sign on fast enough. I'm not shocked. Nobody asked for a cart that barks orders at them in the aisle, no matter how helpful it's supposed to be. The money is moving to smart price tags and cameras that track what's on the shelf.
DoorDash, meanwhile, built its own delivery robot, Dot, which is already rolling around Phoenix and Fremont. It also works with Wing on drones and with Coco and Serve Robotics on sidewalk robots. Put the two R&D budgets together and autonomous delivery could move a lot faster. And if I'm DoorDash, the robot companies I already work with start to look a lot like shopping. Uber just sold its stake in Serve Robotics, so the door is open.
5. Same rule as always: check the homework
We don't love any retail media network grading its own homework, and a bigger one won't change that. In-platform results are directional, not gospel. They rarely are.
It's also worth remembering that delivery apps reach the people who order delivery. Most grocery shopping still happens in the store, and a lot of growth comes from light buyers who may never open either app. So measure sales lift across all of your retail, not only the orders that came through the platform, and use an independent way to check it.
The biggest delivery platform in the country is still a slice of the market. Plan like it.
We are Left Hand Agency, a CPG media buying agency helping brands grow with short and long-term strategies. Our memory-driven strategies deliver results your marketing and finance teams will champion.



