top of page
Search

5 Ways Your Advertising Changes When You Move from DTC to In-Store | Left Hand Agency CPG High Five

11 minutes ago
6 min read

Landing in Target, Kroger, or Walmart is a big deal. It’s champagne-toast, all-caps-LinkedIn-post big. Then the hard part starts.


Most of your new customers are going to meet you in a store. Online grocery hit a record share of spending in Q3 2026, and still, about 79% of grocery dollars got spent in person. Even the online slice mostly happens on Walmart, Amazon, and Instacart, where you’re one product in a long scroll of options.


Here’s what throws DTC brands for a loop. On your own site, you’re the only thing for sale. Someone clicks your ad, lands on your page, and the only thing they can buy is you. In the aisle, you’re one box among dozens, next to brands people have been buying for 20 years, and the shopper decides in a few seconds. Winning that moment takes different advertising, and it costs more.


That’s where things usually go sideways. Brands that never had brand building in the budget try to run the DTC playbook in the aisle. They move the Meta money into retail media sponsored search, watch the ROAS come back looking great, and pour in some more.


It works. Right up until it catastrophically doesn’t.


Sponsored search is great at catching people already shopping your category, but it does very little to bring new people in. A brand most shoppers haven’t heard of doesn’t have much demand to catch. Meanwhile, the real cost of competing for attention starts eating into a margin nobody planned for.


Retail buyers have noticed. They’ve stopped putting much stock in DTC sales numbers because those numbers weren’t turning into sell-through on the shelf.


So here are five ways your advertising has to change when you go from add to cart to aisle 7.


1. Your scoreboard changes. 


Split infographic with ROAS on left and Sales Lift, velocity, and Brand Health on right

In DTC, ROAS was the whole game. You spent a dollar, watched it come back with friends and felt great about yourself. In stores, ROAS still has a job. You can measure it on Instacart ads or Walmart’s onsite display, and you should. But it’s a channel-level metric for performance media, and it has two big blind spots.


It can’t tell you whether those sales would have happened anyway (that’s incrementality), and it can’t see the huge number of people who only ever buy you in the store. Being easy to measure doesn’t make it the most important number in the room.


Brands that grow in retail watch sales lift, changes in velocity (how many units each store sells per week), and brand health metrics like awareness and consideration, which tend to



2. Mental availability has to meet physical availability. 


Being on the shelf doesn’t help if nobody walking past has heard of you, and being famous doesn’t help in a town where nobody stocks you. So the media goes where you’re actually sold. We steer it with two distribution numbers: ACV, which shows how much of a market’s grocery business runs through stores that carry you, and TDP (total distribution points), which also factors in how many of your items those stores stock. Where those numbers are strongest is where the reach goes first.


If you’re about to open new doors, it’s smart to start warming up that market a little early, but keep it close to launch and close to the shelf. 


Native is a great example. When Native moved into Target and Walmart, 80% to 90% of its ad spend had been going to Google and Facebook. It started buying streaming and cable TV, beginning in big metros and spreading into suburban and rural markets. Its founder pointed out that a lot of suburban shoppers aren’t ready to buy online from a brand they don’t know. They’ll grab it off a shelf, though, if they’ve seen it before.


3. Your creative stops chasing the click while advertising. 


Hand holding a phone with a Facebook adidas ad for running shoes, 20% OFF, beside a city building covered in bright Lay's billboards.

Performance ads and brand ads have two very different jobs. Performance ads capture demand that already exists. They ask you to do something right now (“shop now, 20% off!”), and an ad that gives you a task gets filed in short-term memory and tossed once the moment passes.


Brand ads build the memory. They create an emotional response and plant your name so you come to mind when someone is ready to buy. (Binet and Field have spent years showing that emotional brand advertising is what drives long-term growth.)


That matters a lot in a store, because shoppers don’t study the whole aisle. They walk in with a few brands already in their head and grab one of those. If you aren’t on that short list, you’re probably not getting picked, and the way onto the list is brand advertising that keeps building over time.


Run the performance playbook alone and nothing compounds.

In your ads, show the package so people can spot it, and tell them where to find you. Magic Spoon did this when it hit Target and Sprouts, pointing its influencers toward “grab it in store” instead of “order online.”


4. Go big at launch, then don't disappear. 


The first few months in a new retailer are basically a tryout. The buyer is watching your velocity, and a slow start can get you cut at the next shelf reset. So performance goes in first. Retail media, Instacart ads, and other tactics close to the purchase drive trial and get units moving right away.


But brand belongs in the mix as early as you can manage it, because it makes your performance ads work harder and its effects keep paying off long after the campaign ends.


We plan launches with heavier reach and frequency than normal. After that, recency takes over. Erwin Ephron, the media researcher who popularized recency planning, argued that an ad does its best work when it reaches someone close to when they’re ready to buy. So the goal becomes staying present when people are shopping. That might mean always-on, seasonal pulses, or whatever rhythm fits the category.


The heavy-up gets you noticed. Staying on keeps you on the shelf.


5. Retail media is a line item. The store is the bigger prize. 


Split scene of a Walmart storefront and grocery aisle, with a large Colgate ad, shoppers, and parked cars under a cloudy sky.

Your retailer will probably ask you to spend on its media network, and it has a role, mostly catching shoppers who are already searching. But most of the buying still happens in the store, and the store has more ways to win than ever: merchandising, shelf placement, endcaps and displays, in-store screens and audio, and sampling, which is still one of the best ways to get someone to try a brand they’ve never heard of.


There have never been more ways to make that last-aisle impression. That’s also the problem. Every option comes with a sales pitch and a price tag, so weigh them against each other and against the rest of your plan, or the in-store budget will get away from you fast.


Bonus: the stuff nobody puts in the pitch deck


Packaging has to work at shelf distance. What looked great as a thumbnail on Instagram can disappear next to 40 other boxes under fluorescent lights. Make sure people can spot you from a few feet away. But don’t toss a look people already recognize for a complete redesign unless you have a really good reason. You’d be starting over on recognition you already paid to build.


Slotting fees and trade spend. Congratulations, you’ve earned the privilege of paying for your own shelf space. Add in promos, free fills, chargebacks, and freight, and a lot of the money you thought was for advertising can vanish before your first ad runs. Plan for it up front.


Cash gets tight. Retailers can take months to pay you, and your suppliers still want their money now. You can sell more than ever and still run short on cash, which is usually when the media budget gets cut, right when you need it most.


Your DTC sales may dip. Some of your online customers will start buying you in the store instead. That’s normal, but it makes the impact of new distribution harder to read. Before launch, have a plan to measure total brand sales across every channel so you know what the new stores actually added.


If you’re a DTC brand with your eye on a shelf someday, start planning for it now. Know what the opportunity looks like, what you’ll need to spend on day one, and how cost, channels, and measurement all change once you’re in the aisle. 


And don’t wait for a purchase order to start building your brand. Brand advertising helps your DTC business today and gives you a head start the day you land in stores. It pays off online and in the aisle.



We are Left Hand Agency, a CPG media buying agency helping brands grow with short and long-term strategies. Our memory-driven strategies deliver results your marketing and finance teams will champion.

 
 
Left Hand Agency Logo

Ready to grow with smarter media?
Let's connect.

  • White LinkedIn Icon
  • YouTube Icon
  • White Facebook Icon
WOSB Certified Logo
WBENC Certified Logo
WBE Logo
ESB Logo
OSBE Logo
NextNW Logo
Indie Agency News Logo
Thank you for contacting us!

Left Hand Agency | Portland, OR | Serving CPG & Retail Brands Nationwide | (414) 897-2146

© 2026 by Left Hand Agency

bottom of page